Theory and Method of Public Administration
PA 705
Fall 2004
Style Sheet for Team Survey Project
The purpose of this assignments is to give you practice in developing and administering a survey, and in analyzing and reporting its results. Surveys are a very popular means for collecting information on people's attitudes and behavior, and many local governments use them to gauge the extent to which citizens are satisfied with city-provided services. This project, unlike your prospectus, also provides you with the opportunity to collect original data, and analyze it using the quantitative and qualitative analytical techniques we discuss in class. Finally, it gives you practice in working as part of a team, figuring out the best way to distribute the work and to reach common agreement on findings and conclusions.
I will assign you to teams at the end of class on Sept. 22. You will have an opportunity to meet with your team during class on the 29th. A draft of your survey instrument is due October 13, and your final, written report, is due on the last day of class.
Requirements
Decide on a topic for your survey. Once you have done this, your next step would be too look at what other research has been done on this topic. However, since I am requiring a literature review for your prospectus, I will allow you to skip that step for this assignment
Develop three hypotheses that can be tested with the survey. These should be phrased as a relationship between variables. For example, if your topic is the public's perceptions about the future viability of social security, your hypothesis might be "the younger the person, the greater their pessimism about social security."
Draft a brief survey instrument. The instrument should include a maximum of 15 questions that can be used to test your hypotheses. These should include:
|
closed ended questions that record the individuals' attitudes or behavior with respect to your topic (e.g., level of agreement or disagreement with the statement "I am confident that social security will still be viable when I retire") | |
|
demographic questions that are necessary to test your hypotheses (e.g., in the social security case, age) | |
|
one open ended question that allows people to provide a narrative answer |
Please also consult ORB chapter 7. I also suggest that you pretest the survey by administering it to a few people (not on your team) and asking them whether the questions were clear, response categories comprehensive, etc. Please turn in your draft survey to me on Oct. 13 so I can make suggestions for improvement.
Identify survey population and select a sample. Whose views do you need to get to test your hypotheses? In my social security case, they would need to be people from various age groups. Normally, you would want to pull a random sample from your population of interest. But for the purpose of this assignment, you can use a "convenience" sample, of people you know or otherwise can get access to. You should plan to survey 75-100 people.
Administer the survey. Decide whether you will do this verbally (e.g. over the phone, in person) or in writing (see ORB chapter 6).
Code and enter the data into a spreadsheet that can be analyzed using a statistical software package (e.g., SPSS)
Perform the analyses you need to do to test your hypotheses. These should include bivariate analysis (see ORB Chapter 12, 13). You may also want to use multivariate analysis such as multiple regression (see ORB chapter 14). Be sure to also use tests of statistical significance. Technically, these don't mean much if your sample wasn't drawn randomly, but I would like you to practice using them. Be sure to include discussion of the responses to your open-ended question.
Write up your results. Your final write-up is due at the last class meeting. This should be a paper, not to exceed 10 pages that includes
|
An introduction to your topic and why it is important | |
|
A statement of your hypotheses | |
|
A brief summary of your methodology (how you selected the sample, administered the survey, coded the data, as well as the procedures used to analyze the data) | |
|
A discussion of your findings and conclusions (see ORB chapter 15). I would encourage you to use tables and graphs to highlight your more important findings. When reporting on differences between groups, make sure you include the "p" value associated with your test of statistical significance | |
|
Complete the paper with a final overall concluding paragraph |
In addition, please include the following appendices:
|
Your survey instrument | |
|
The SPSS output that you used to generate your reported results | |
|
A brief discussion of decisions you made and problems you ran into carrying out the assignment. |
Complete the confidential team member evaluation form and e-mail it to me, or bring it to the last class meeting.
Grading
You will receive a team grade for the assignment, which will be based on:
|
The extent to which you carried out all the necessary steps (listed above) to complete the survey project | |
|
The extent to which you designed a survey instrument, chose an appropriate sample, and ran quantitative procedures (including tests of statistical significance) to test your hypotheses | |
|
The extent to which you effectively presented and discussed your results | |
|
The quality of your written report--it's organization, clarity and logic. |
Your individual grade may be raised or lowered based on the confidential team member evaluations provided by your teammates
Survey Teams
| Team A | Team B | Team C | Team D |
| Lexy | Kari | Jennifer | Caitrin |
| Ingrid | John | Janet | Joanne |
| Brian | Christine | Thomas | Rob |
| Sakura | Kuriko | Renay | Sirinut |
| Vadim | Art | Aglae | Lily |