PA 700

Fall 2007

 

San Francisco Campus

Style Sheet for Ethical Dilemma Paper

Due October 29

The purpose of this assignment is to engage your thinking about ethical and other dilemmas facing public administrators, and to do so in a context that you will hopefully find enjoyable (a mystery novel).  As eminent PA scholar Dwight Waldo once wrote, "Through literary treatments we can more closely come to grips with the psychological and moral aspects of administrative decision-making."  To that, William T. Gormley adds about mysteries: "[they] feature stark, vivid examples of bureaucratic conflicts and ethical dilemmas, with high stakes certain to grab the reader's attention and concentrate the mind."

For this assignment you should choose one of the mysteries listed below, or propose another to me. My only criteria is that the protagonist is a public servant, and that the book provides you with enough content to address the following questions:

bulletWhat is (are) the precise nature of the ethical dilemma(s) faced by the public servant in this mystery? For example, in carrying out his or her job, does the public servant have to decide whether to
bulletBreak the law?  
bulletIgnore lesser crimes?
bulletTell lies?
bulletDisobey orders?
bulletUse excessive force?
bulletEngage in any other behavior that you would perceive as unethical?

bulletConsidering the context in which the questionable behavior occurred, would you consider it, in fact, to be unethical?  Why or why not?

bulletShould the public servant be held liable for any of these behaviors, or should she or he be granted some kind of immunity? For what reasons?

bulletIn committing those acts (lying, breaking the law, etc.) does the public servant risk undermining the legitimacy of the government entity he or she works for, in your view?

bulletAre there other risks to the public servant's behavior; that is, ways in which the public might be harmed?

bulletWhich of Waldo's "obligations" does the public servant violate (See Stillman, pp 504-514) and which of ASPA's code of ethics (click here).


Organization and Style

The  paper must  not exceed 5 pages, double-spaced. Make sure you begin with a brief introduction and conclude with a brief summary of your main points.  Please also include a brief synopsis of the situation(s) you are referring to in your discussion of the ethical dilemma(s). Your grade will be based on the extent to which it addresses the points listed above.  It should address them within the context of a narrative essay, not in a question-answer format.  Your grade will also be based on the paper's clarity, conciseness, creativity and logic of organization. Subtitles are encouraged as they can help to make the organization clear.

 

Partial List of Acceptable Mysteries

Author

Books

Nevada Barr

A Superior Death

  Ill Wind
  Blind Descent
   
Michael Connelly The Black Echo
  The Black Ice
   
Patricia Cornwell Post-Mortem
  Body of Evidence
  Cruel and Unusual
   
Michael Dibdin Ratking
  Vendetta
  Cabal
  Cosi Fan Tutti
  A Long Finish
   
Earl Emerson Black Hearts and Slow Dancing
  Help Wanted
   
Linda Farstein Cold Hit
   
Elizabeth George Payment in Blood
  Deception on His Mind
   
Tony Hillerman Dance Hall of the Dead
  Skinwalkers
  A Thief of Time
  The First Eagle
   
P.D. James The Black Tower
  A Taste for Death
   
Stuart Kaminsky Black Knight in Red Square
  A Cold Red Sunrise
  Death of a Russian Priest
  Death of a Dissident
   
Archer Mayor Open Season
  Bellows Falls
   
Ian Rankin Black and Blue
  Let it Bleed