Internship Information | Student Internship Portfolios | Resources | Contact

CalStudies : NPS Internships : Education : Alcatraz : Lori Brosnan : Frank Firmat
Frank Firmat
E-mail: frankfirmat@hotmail.com
Area of Service: Education
Park Site: Alcatraz Island
Mentor: Lori Brosnan
Spring 2004

Overview:
For my Spring 2004 internship I chose to work with the Golden Gate National Park Service on Alcatraz in the San Francisco Bay. I worked on the island once a week under the tutelage of Park Ranger Lori Brosnan. Lori specializes in interpreting and presenting the history of Alcatraz to the visiting public. In my time volunteering on Alcatraz I contributed to the conservation effort by working directly with the visiting public. I worked a total of 84 hours as a docent and performed some of the duties of a park ranger on the island.
 
Portfolio Items:
 - Résumé
 - Description of the National Park Service
 - Description of Internship
 - Evaluation of Internship
 - Photographs of the Internship

Résumé (to be updated soon!)

Objective ·
Education ·
Relevant Coursework ·
Related Skills · 
Related Employment · 
Projects  · 
Awards · 
Volunteer Experience · Alcatraz Island, Educational Guide for National Park

Description of NPS, GGNRA, and Alcatraz Island

NPS:
The goal of the National Park Service is, “…to conserve the scenery and the natural and historical objects and the wildlife therein and to provide for the enjoyment of the same in such a manner and by such means as will leave them unimpaired for the enjoyment of future generations.” In my time volunteering on Alcatraz I helped in the conservation effort by working directly with the visiting public. (Anonymous - Volunteer Training Manual 2003)

The National Park Service was established in 1916 by President Woodrow Wilson. At that time the Interior Department was responsible for 14 national parks and 21 national monuments but had no organization to maintain or manage them. On August 25, 1916 the National Park Service Act (also known as the Park Services “Organic Act”) was signed and the NPS was born. As stated above the mission of the NPS is to conserve and provide for the enjoyment of the parks for future generations. (Rothman & Holder 2004)

GGNRA:
The Golden Gate National Recreation Area is one of the most popular National Park units. It spans 75,398 acres of land and water and is almost two and a half times the size of San Francisco. The GGNRA includes a number of very diverse sites such as: Crissy Field, Alcatraz, Muir Woods, Nike Missile Site, and Fort Point. A great deal of the work and maintenance in the recreation areas is done by volunteers. The GGNRA is also supported by the Golden Gate National Parks Conservancy a non profit organization that has raised $52 million dollars since its inception in. (Anonymous, The Parks Conservancy – About the Parks Association 2004) (Rothman & Holder 2004)

Alcatraz Island:
In 1972 the island of Alcatraz became part of the Golden Gate National Recreation Area. The island itself is only 22 acre and is visited by almost 1.5 million national and international visitors. Located only 1.5 miles from San Francisco and 3 miles from the Bay and the Golden Gate Bridge, Alcatraz is significant because of its rich history. The island is famous for having the first lighthouse on the Pacific coast, for being the site of a military fortification during the gold rush, serving as a military and later a federal prison, and it was claimed as “Indian land” before becoming a National Park. It is this rich history that the NPS seeks to conserve for future generations. (Anonymous - Volunteer Training Manual 2003) (Esslinger 2004)

Alcatraz is also a major nesting ground for native birds. The most common is the Western Gull, though three kinds of Cormorants also inhabit the island. The island is an ideal place for nesting because there are no nature water sources, and in turn, no predators. Alcatraz is one of the largest nesting grounds for the Western Gull and the NPS creates policy and takes action to protect the nesting birds as part of the natural environment. (Anonymous - Volunteer Training Manual 2003). 

Description of Alcatraz Island Education Internship 

For my spring 2004 internship I chose to work with the Golden Gate National Park Service on Alcatraz in the San Francisco Bay. I worked on the island once a week under the tutelage of Park Ranger Lori Brosnan. Lori specializes in interpreting and presenting the history of Alcatraz to the visiting public. In my time volunteering on Alcatraz I contributed to the conservation effort by working directly with the visiting public. I worked a total of 84 hours as a docent and performed some of the duties of a park ranger on the island.

The majority of my time was spent interacting with the visiting public. I would gather the visitors (up to 300 at times) as they stepped onto the island and then would proceed with the “dock greetings.” Dock greetings consisted of telling the visitors about: the park rules and regulations, programs and tours, short stories about the history of the park, and answering any questions they might have. Alcatraz has over a million visitors a year from all over the world so the language barriers could be challenging at times. 
I also worked with smaller groups while on Alcatraz. During my day I’d spend around two hours walking the ground and leading small behind the scenes tours. The groups were usually school groups or families of tourist ranging in size from 2 to 10 as opposed to the massive crowds of 300 that came off the boat every half hour. I would walk and talk with the group, teaching them about a certain aspect of the history as we passed through the physical remains. 

Part of my internship was also spent operating audio/video machinery, organizing the dock office, and preparing for the first park visitors. Starting the films, keeping track of visiting school groups, posting program times and other preparation work was a necessary part of the job. I would sometimes handle tools for the group in charge of garden restoration or put calls in to Blue & Gold (the boat company that handles transportation to and from the island) when alarms went off because of sewage or power issues. In rare cases I would be called upon for minor first aid assistance and would later record anything of significance in the daily log book. Essentially I performed a number of problem-solving tasks that are necessary in running an operation of this size.

Finally, I spent a part of each day researching in the private Alcatraz library to fortify my knowledge of the island. The Ranger office has a small library devoted to the history of Alcatraz. I spent time reading through books that addressed different aspects of the island like the native plant and bird life, the 19 month Native American occupation, and the prison years, both military and federal. I also took the opportunity to read through FBI investigations and reports on a few of the classic escape attempts. This was a rare opportunity to increase my knowledge through original reports and black and white photos. The time I spent researching was key for advancing my knowledge for small tours and fueling the visitor’s interest in the park and its history. (Anonymous - Volunteer Training Manual 2003) (Esslinger 2004)

I received on site training throughout my internship. Lori Brosnan and the rest of the NPS and Conservancy staff modeled effective ways to communicate with the large number of visitors each day. Lori emphasized that the best way to get a person interested in history is to relate it to something they already know from everyday living. I was also shown how to operate some of the prison machinery, such as the prison door system, as well as how to access the areas that are closed to the public. Much of my training was spent watching the staff relate the history of the island through dock greetings, large tours, and private behind the scenes tours.

My previous job experience helped to prepare me for my internship on Alcatraz. Before starting at SF State I taught 5th and 6th graders at an outdoor science program in the San Bernardino Mountains for two and a half years. Creating and presenting programs for visiting schools of Jr. High students helped prepare me for the public speaking aspect of the internship. I was comfortable explaining the history of Alcatraz to children as well as adult because of my time spent teaching. At the science school I lead nature hikes for staff, students, and their teachers and I gained an understanding of how to communicate most efficiently with the varying age groups. This experience was called upon throughout my internship when giving tours to families or helping lost children find their parents. 

My Work Unit:
I volunteered to work with the NPS on Alcatraz as part of an internship at San Francisco State. I worked with the Rangers, the Conservancy staff and other interns and volunteers. Through my efforts and hour spent volunteering I helped maintain the NPS operations on Alcatraz and supported the long term goals of the Park Service. Though I only worked a total of 84 hours, my actions were in alignment with the NPS mission statement. I contributed by protecting the native plant and animal life and by communicating the rich history of the island to the visitors. My internship supported the conservation of Alcatraz Island National Park for the enjoyment of current and future generations.

Evaluation of Internship

The internship on Alcatraz provided opportunities for development and growth. While there I experienced the National Park Service environment, professionalism, and communication process. The scope of my public speaking skills broadened and improved and I gained a genuine interest in the layers of history that are present on the island. My 84 hours spent with the National Park Service expanded my knowledge and improved my job related skills.

While working on Alcatraz I had the opportunity to interact with the Rangers, volunteers, and members of the Golden Gate National Parks Conservancy. The office work environment on Alcatraz was professional and problems were dealt with in a thorough and communicative way. Working in the Park Service requires frequent meetings and I saw they were all part of the process in running a National Park as complex as Alcatraz. Many interests are involved in the decision making process on the island and it was interesting to watch these negotiations take place. While working in the office I experienced the thorough workings of a National Park. 

Speaking in front of people each day greatly improved my communication skills and my confidence in front of large groups. Almost 1.5 million people come to Alcatraz each year and a large number of them are international travelers. I interacted with people from all over the world and presented to tourists whose native tongue was not English. This was a unique experience in terms of cultural relativity and communication. After my internship I am better equipped to speak with groups large or small, young and old, domestic and international. (Rothman & Holder 2004)

Under Lori’s tutelage my teaching techniques were refined. Before this internship I’d taught very little history. I learned to connect the history to something a person could relate to. For instance if I were trying to convey the psychological hardships of prison life on Alcatraz to a child it might look like this: “So have you ever heard about a birthday party that you weren’t invited to, or some fun event that your friends were all going to, but you couldn’t? Well that sad feeling of missing out is what the prisoners felt all the time because they were so close to the city, but couldn’t leave the island. Sometimes they could even hear music and parties from across the water…” Basically, using an experience someone has had and then tying that into some aspect of Alcatraz history.

While teaching visitors about the history of Alcatraz I gained an interest in American history that I didn’t have before. I learned quite a bit of history about the island and how it’s changed over the years. I found myself reading and researching outside of my internship hours because I wanted to learn more. The internship produced an interest in American history because of the way the island changed with the times (for example the Native American occupation and movement in 1969). I finished my time on Alcatraz with a greater understanding of history as well as an interest in learning more. (Rubissow 1990) (Anonymous - Volunteer Training Manual 2003)